Is Retinyl Palmitate (Vitamin A Palmitate) Comedogenic?
In the 1989 rabbit-ear study by Fulton, retinyl palmitate (vitamin a palmitate) (listed in the paper as “Vitamin A palmitate”) was graded 1–3 out of 5 for comedogenicity, which is moderate. Irritancy was graded 1–3. The paper notes that the result depends on the source of the raw material.
- Comedogenicity (0–5)
- 1–3
- Irritancy (0–5)
- 1–3
- Name in the paper
- Vitamin A palmitate
- Group in the paper
- Vitamins and herbs
- Source
- Fulton 1989, Table I, page 326
Names you may see on a label
Retinyl Palmitate. These pairs are our own reading of today’s label names against the 1989 paper.
What the grade means
The study applied the pure ingredient to rabbit ears and graded how much it plugged hair follicles, from 0 (none) to 5 (severe). It tested single ingredients, not finished products, and it says the vehicle an ingredient is delivered in changes the result. A grade is a reason to look closer or patch test, not a verdict on a product. Labels list ingredients from most to least, so position matters too.
Check a whole ingredient list that contains it
Others in the same group
- Tocopherol (vitamin E) — 0–3
- A & D additive — 2
- Black walnut extract — 0
- Chamomile extract — 0
- Panthenol — 0
- Papain — 0
- Tocopheryl acetate — 0
Source: Fulton JE Jr. Comedogenicity and irritancy of commonly used ingredients in skin care products. J Soc Cosmet Chem. 1989;40:321–333. Table I. How we use it.