About & sources
What this checker is built on, how it matches names, and what it cannot tell you.
The source
Every grade on this site comes from one paper:
Fulton JE Jr. Comedogenicity and irritancy of commonly used ingredients in skin care products. J Soc Cosmet Chem. 1989;40:321–333. Table I.
Table I of that paper grades 219 ingredients for comedogenicity and irritancy on a 0–5 scale. We copied the table row by row and checked each row against enlarged images of pages 324–326. One printed row, “Hydantoin”, has no numbers in the paper and is left out. The full table is here.
We did not copy any other checker’s list, and we do not add grades of our own.
How names are matched
- A name on your label is matched to the paper only when the whole name matches. There is no “close enough” matching, so squalane is not confused with squalene and laureth-7 is not confused with laureth-4.
- Labels today use different names from a 1989 paper. We keep a list of 118 name pairs, for example “Cocos Nucifera Oil” for what the paper calls “coconut butter”. These pairs are our own reading. When a match came through one of them, the result shows both names.
- When a list contains both cetearyl alcohol and ceteareth-20, the result adds the grade the paper gives for the two together.
- Where the paper prints a range such as 2–3, the higher number decides whether it reaches your flag line.
Ingredients flagged by other checkers
Some ingredients that other checkers flag, such as algae extract and carrageenan, are not in the 1989 table. On November 18, 2026 we pasted 68 ingredients into two widely used checkers and wrote down what each flagged. 24 ingredients that are not in the study were flagged by one or both. The result marks these as “flagged elsewhere” and says by how many. We could not find a published grade for them, so we show none.
What this cannot tell you
- Whether a product will break you out. The study tested single ingredients, not finished formulas, and it notes that the vehicle changes the result.
- How much of an ingredient is in the product. Labels give the order, not the amount.
- Anything about ingredients the study did not test.
- Anything medical. If your skin is not improving, see a dermatologist.
Your data
The check runs in your browser. Your ingredient list is not sent anywhere. The site sets no cookies and loads nothing from other sites. Your chosen flag line is saved in your browser so it is still there next time. A shared link carries the list after the # sign, which browsers do not send to servers.
Who pays for this
Nobody. There are no ads, no affiliate links and no products for sale on this site.